Meta announced the Discovery Feed rollout in September 2025 with their usual fanfare about "connecting communities" and "empowering creators." Translation: they completely rewired how content gets distributed, and most marketers are still posting like it's 2024.
I've spent the last three months testing this across 40+ accounts—everything from local coffee shops to B2B SaaS brands. The results have been... let's say humbling for anyone who thought they had Instagram figured out.
Here's the thing: the old playbook is genuinely dead. Hashtag strategies that worked six months ago? Irrelevant. Posting times you optimized for years? Barely matter anymore. That carefully crafted grid aesthetic? The algorithm literally cannot see it.
But some accounts are absolutely crushing it. One client went from 2,000 impressions per post to 45,000 in six weeks. Another saw their follower growth rate triple without changing their content quality at all—just the distribution strategy.
So what's actually working?
Understanding the Discovery Feed (Because Meta's Documentation Is... Vague)
The Discovery Feed isn't just a new tab. It's a fundamental shift in how Instagram surfaces content to people who don't follow you yet.
Think of it like TikTok's For You page had a baby with Pinterest's recommendation engine. Instagram is now aggressively pushing content to users based on interest signals rather than social graphs. Your follower count matters less. Content relevance matters more.
The feed pulls from three primary sources:
- Accounts you don't follow but Instagram thinks you'll like
- Content from hashtags and topics you've engaged with
- Posts that are performing well in your extended network
Meta's official guidance says to "create authentic, engaging content." Thanks, guys. Super helpful. Right up there with "just be yourself" as actionable advice.
What they're not saying: the Discovery Feed heavily weights specific engagement patterns in the first 90 minutes after posting. And I mean heavily. We're seeing posts that get early saves and shares getting 10-15x the reach of posts with similar like counts.
Tactic 1: The 90-Minute Window Is Everything Now
Forget optimizing for posting times based on when your followers are online. That was the old game.
The Discovery Feed looks at velocity—how quickly you accumulate specific engagement signals in that first hour and a half. A post that gets 50 saves in 90 minutes will dramatically outperform one that gets 200 likes in the same timeframe.
Here's what we're doing:
Pre-announce valuable posts to your most engaged followers. Stories, DMs to your top 20 commenters, even a quick email if you have a list. Tell them when the post drops and why they should save it. This feels manipulative until you realize everyone competing for Discovery Feed placement is doing some version of this.
Structure posts for immediate saves. Listicles, how-to guides, resource compilations—content people want to reference later. One client switched from inspirational quotes to "bookmark this" tactical posts and their Discovery Feed impressions jumped 340%.
Time your posts around when your power users are active. Not your whole audience—your top 50 most engaged followers. Instagram Insights shows you this now. These people trigger the initial velocity that kicks you into Discovery.
A local bakery I work with posts at 6:47 AM. Weird time, right? That's when their 30 most loyal customers are having coffee and scrolling. Those early engagements launch every post into Discovery by 8 AM, reaching thousands of local food enthusiasts who've never heard of them.
Tactic 2: Topic Clustering Beats Hashtag Spam
Remember when we'd research 30 hashtags per post and rotate them to avoid "shadowbanning"? Yeah, that's not how this works anymore.
The Discovery Feed uses semantic analysis to understand what your post is actually about. It's looking at your caption text, any text in your image, your historical content patterns, and engagement signals to categorize your content into interest topics.
Hashtags still matter, but differently. Think of them as topic declarations rather than discovery tools.
Use 3-5 highly specific hashtags instead of 30 generic ones. We're seeing better results with #ChicagoSpecialtyCoffee than #Coffee #CoffeeLovers #CoffeePorn and 27 other variations. The algorithm already knows your post is about coffee. You're just helping it understand the specific niche.
Stay in your lane for 15-20 posts. If you post about fitness, then skincare, then business strategy, the algorithm has no idea what topics to surface you in. One account we work with committed to only posting about sustainable fashion for a month. Their Discovery Feed reach increased 5x because Instagram finally understood where to distribute them.
Use consistent terminology in captions. If you call something "content strategy" in one post and "content planning" in another, you're splitting your topic authority. Pick your terms and stick with them. This connects to broader content strategy principles around message consistency—something we've covered extensively in our AI content marketing guide.
A fitness coach I advise was posting workout tips, nutrition advice, mindset content, and product reviews. All valuable, but scattered. She committed to 30 days of only "home workouts for busy parents." Her Discovery impressions went from 800 per post to 12,000. The algorithm finally knew exactly who to show her content to.
Tactic 3: Shares Are the New Likes (And It's Not Even Close)
This is the biggest shift and most people still haven't caught on.
Instagram's internal weighting for the Discovery Feed prioritizes shares over every other metric. A share signals "this is so good I need to show someone else," which is exactly what Instagram wants to surface to new audiences.
We've tested this extensively. Posts with high like counts but low shares barely touch Discovery. Posts with moderate engagement but strong share rates absolutely explode.
Create content worth sending to a specific person. Generic inspirational quotes don't get shared. "5 responses when a client asks for a discount" gets sent to every freelancer's group chat. See the difference?
Add a share prompt that gives people a reason. Not "share this if you agree" (nobody does that). Try "Send this to someone who needs to hear it" or "Share this with your team." We tested this across 30 accounts and saw share rates increase 60-80%.
Make carousel posts that tell a complete story. Shares on carousels count more heavily because Instagram knows the person had to engage enough to swipe through. A single-image post might get a pity share. A 10-slide tactical breakdown gets shared because it has real value.
One B2B account posted "7 email templates that actually get responses." Simple carousel, each slide was a template. It got 340 shares in three days and reached 89,000 people—15x their follower count. The content was shareable because it solved a specific problem for a specific person.
Tactic 4: Comment Depth Triggers Distribution
The algorithm isn't just counting comments anymore. It's analyzing them.
A post with 50 single-emoji comments performs worse in Discovery than a post with 15 multi-sentence conversations. Instagram is looking for genuine engagement, not engagement bait.
Ask specific questions that require thoughtful answers. "What's your biggest challenge with X?" generates better responses than "Double tap if you agree!" One account switched from generic CTAs to specific questions and saw their average comment length triple. Their Discovery reach doubled.
Respond to every comment in the first hour with follow-up questions. This creates threads, which the algorithm loves. Don't just say "thanks!"—ask something that continues the conversation. "That's a great point about Y—have you tried Z approach?"
Seed the conversation with your own detailed comment. Post your content, then immediately add a comment with additional context or your own answer to the question you posed. This sets the tone and gives people something to respond to beyond the original post.
A marketing consultant I work with started posting case studies and then adding a detailed comment breaking down what she'd do differently now. People respond to her comment, she responds back, suddenly there are 30-comment threads. Her Discovery Feed impressions increased 280% in five weeks.
Nothing says "authentic engagement" like actually engaging authentically. Shocking, I know.
Tactic 5: Cross-Post Strategically to Feed the Algorithm
Instagram wants to keep people on the platform longer. If you can move people from Discovery Feed to Reels to Stories to your profile, you're giving Instagram exactly what it wants.
Create content series across formats. Post a carousel in feed, create a Reel expanding on one slide, use Stories to show behind-the-scenes. Link them together. The algorithm notices when people engage with you across multiple formats and pushes you harder in Discovery.
Use Stories to drive engagement to feed posts. The old advice was to post to feed and then share to Stories. Flip it. Tease the feed post in Stories first, build curiosity, then post to feed. Your engaged Story viewers hit that post immediately, triggering the velocity signals that launch you into Discovery.
Repurpose top Discovery performers into Reels. When a feed post crushes it in Discovery, turn that concept into a Reel within 48 hours. Instagram's recommendation systems talk to each other. A post performing well in one area gets preferential treatment in others.
One account posted a tactical carousel that hit Discovery hard. Three days later, they created a Reel covering the same topic with a different angle. That Reel got 4x their normal Reel views because the algorithm had already identified the topic as high-performing for their audience.
The platforms are converging anyway. Instagram is slowly becoming one unified recommendation engine rather than separate feeds. Fighting that is pointless. Work with it.
What About AI and Automation?
Look, everyone's talking about AI content tools right now. Can they help with Discovery Feed optimization?
Sort of. AI is genuinely useful for generating post variations to test, analyzing which caption structures get more saves, and identifying topic clusters in your niche. We've been experimenting with AI-assisted content strategies and the results are mixed but promising.
But here's the reality: the Discovery Feed rewards genuine human engagement and authentic value. AI can help you create more efficiently, but it can't fake the engagement signals that matter. You still need real people to save, share, and comment thoughtfully on your content.
The accounts crushing Discovery Feed aren't using AI to generate everything. They're using it to augment their process while keeping the human insight and value creation at the center.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Organic Reach
Even with perfect Discovery Feed optimization, organic reach isn't what it was in 2016. It's never going back to that.
Instagram is a business. They make money from ads. The Discovery Feed is partly about user experience and partly about creating more ad inventory. Understanding that helps you set realistic expectations.
That said, the Discovery Feed is the best opportunity for organic growth Instagram has offered in years. Accounts that nail these tactics are reaching 10-20x their follower counts regularly. That's real distribution.
But it requires actually providing value. Generic content, engagement bait, and recycled motivational quotes won't cut it. The algorithm is pretty good at identifying low-effort content now.
You need to create things people genuinely want to save and share. That means understanding your audience deeply, solving specific problems, and being willing to give away your best insights for free.
What's Actually Working Right Now
Let me give you the tactical summary without the fluff:
- Optimize for the 90-minute velocity window with pre-announcement and strategic timing
- Use 3-5 specific hashtags and maintain topic consistency across 15-20 posts
- Create shareable content that solves specific problems for specific people
- Generate comment depth through specific questions and genuine conversation
- Cross-post strategically across formats to signal topic authority
The accounts seeing the biggest Discovery Feed wins are doing all five consistently. Not perfectly—consistently. They're treating Instagram like a value-delivery platform rather than a follower-counting game.
One more thing: this will change. Instagram's algorithm updates constantly. What works in January 2026 might be different by June. The core principles—provide value, encourage meaningful engagement, stay topically consistent—those will remain. The specific tactics will evolve.
Stay flexible. Test constantly. And for the love of all that is holy, stop posting generic motivational quotes with stock photos. The algorithm can smell those from a mile away.
The Discovery Feed is either your biggest opportunity or your biggest frustration in 2026. Which one it becomes depends entirely on whether you're willing to adapt to how Instagram actually works now, not how you wish it still worked.
Top comments (0)